In Phony, Sonny (Sam Nivola) wakes up after a car accident convinced that his beloved mother Ellen (Connie Britton) has been replaced with an impostor; we tell you whether we were interested in watching her fake it ’til she makes it. Ask EHG requires us, among other things, to pitch the WORST possible roles to cast Joel McHale in and share the petty curses we would like to bestow upon our enemies. Tara pitches The Late Show With David Letterman’s 1996 Halloween costume segment for the Tiny Holiday Programming Canon. Then, after we name our Not Quite Winners and Losers of the week, we close things up with a Listener Game Time that kicks the (tin) can. Enjoy it all on your next Costco run!
Real Talk About Phony
Connie Britton plays herself and her doppelgänger in Hulu’s new mystery dramedy!
Club members can listen on
this episode's Patreon page
Episode Rundown
Lead Topic
Ask EHG
Ask Ask EHG
Tiny Canon: Holiday Programming
Winner & Loser
Game Time
Other Tags
Episode Notes
Episode Tags
Episode Transcript
Episode Transcription
Clip
00:06
Here's a good part coming up. When?
Dave
00:15
This is the Extra Extra Hot Great Podcast, episode 435 for the October 24th, 2026 weekend. I am patient beaver David T. Cole, and I'm here with look -alike named Sarah D. Bunting.
Sarah
00:33
Which is why I can't dance.
Dave
00:35
And suggestive desk chair or Tara Ariano
Tara
00:38
We will also be having sex here. Welcome to Extra Extra Hot Great for another week. Thank you so much for your support Port, thank you for making this podcast possible, both this episode and the Wednesday episodes. We are here this week to talk about phony on Hulu, in which Sonny Cook, Sam Nivola, had a pretty great life. His single mother Ellen, Connie Britton, is devoted to him and pretty cool as moms go. His girlfriend Chloe, Mahila Park, is adorable and funny and couldn't be more excited for them to lose their virginities to each other. Sonny seems to be on friendly terms with every student at his high school, where Ellen is the principal. He is then on his way to Chloe's house for their big sex date when a literal beaver fells a tree on the road and he swerves into a notorio When he finally regains consciousness in the hospital about a week later, he is convinced that the woman everyone else accepts as Ellen is not actually her. and embarks upon a quest both to prove this woman is an imposter and find out what happened to his actual mother. This is the first T V show created by Nick Paley, whose credits include co writing the screenplay for Marcel DeCell with Shoes On. The first two episodes dropped on Hulu October 20th. We got access to four, but we'll be careful about spoilers. Let's do the chen check-in. Sarah, should our listeners watch Phony?
Sarah
02:12
I don't actually know, but I'm gonna keep going with it, so cautious yes.
Tara
02:17
Dave
Dave
02:18
Yeah, there are things about the setup of this show I like a lot, but I was just check on my watch a lot during this first four episodes. It's just one of those things that just doesn't move fast enough for me, given its mysterious nature.
Tara
02:34
Right. I'm also a cautious yes, and I wonder if we are cautious yeses for the same reason, Sarah, because first of all, this is, I think, a movie-sized idea that is going to be eight episodes. Second They hook me with good low-key writing, very naturalistic performances. They add a mystery that's strange enough to make me curious about how it ends, but I've been burned by so many supernatural mysteries, especially on TV. And by the time we get to the moment where Sunny is looking at an old video of him with his mother like when he was a kid and it's Ellen 2. I I was like, okay, something not of this world has happened if she has like retroactively replace this person who would go to the trouble of CGI-ing her into this old video like just by chance that he might see it or not.
Dave
03:20
But can't that just be his perception of what's going on?
Tara
03:23
That's true.
Dave
03:24
There is a unreliable slash possibly brain damage narrator involved, so I didn't really have that same reaction to it.
Sarah
03:28
Mm-hmm, yes
Tara
03:28
That's that
Dave
03:31
I thought this could be anything right now. until they firm up exactly what's going on at some point in the future.
Tara
03:38
Okay, well is that Sarah, was that your read as well?
Sarah
03:41
Yeah, I mean I just always assume that it's like, oh, he's dead, or this is a Jacobs Letters situation.
Tara
03:48
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
03:48
I do like that the episodes are at least short. Do there need to be eight of them? Maybe not. We'll see. It's totally possible that people only got four because they kind of knew that there should only be six. But I think they also do a really good job at the world building and then the mystery is like I understand it's the whole central premise of the show, but it also feels more like seasoning in almost in the first episode. I'm not sure if that is going to work for the duration of the season, but it did work for me. I liked those proportions. I liked the characters. I liked the performances and the sort of fond sending up of a certain Pacific Northwest conspiracy weirdo. And uh so yeah, I'm I'm in because I like the people and the sort of mise en
Tara
04:42
Mm-hmm.
Dave
04:43
I'd like the lead, the student, the son of the principal.
Tara
04:47
Sunny
Dave
04:48
Thank you. I thought that felt a little different from what we usually get for this type of story, right?
Tara
04:53
Mm-hmm.
Dave
04:53
Usually it would be the husband or the you know the wife and the wood that would be the
Tara
04:56
Yeah
Dave
04:57
relationship. However, I think there's something wrong just at a fundamental level with this setting, with this premise, with this world I mean, like in the universe. Cause Sonny's too nice. So there's something up with him
Tara
05:10
Hm, okay
Dave
05:11
He's only nice because he's he's had incredible brain damage.
Sarah
05:11
Yeah
Tara
05:16
But he's nice before that
Dave
05:17
I know.
Tara
05:17
too.
Dave
05:18
I'm just saying they're playing around.
Tara
05:18
Sure.
Dave
05:20
My theory is no teenager
Tara
05:20
Yeah
Dave
05:22
's that nice, therefore something happened before the events of Episode Bono Phony to make them that nice. And perhaps this is
Tara
05:26
Mm-hmm.
Dave
05:28
hitting his brain back to where it was supposed to be. Maybe he thought the mother was Connie
Tara
05:31
Right.
Dave
05:33
Britton and in fact it was Fonnie Fritten.
Tara
05:35
Sure.
Dave
05:36
Who knows?
Sarah
05:36
Mm-hmm.
Tara
05:36
Yeah.
Dave
05:37
But I did like the fact that the tale is centric to this student living a life in high school and not necessarily the mother, or not necessarily adults.
Tara
05:47
Mm-hmm. Right. Yeah, I agree with that. I I think they do a good job setting that up very economically in the first episode too, because Mallory, his friend from, you know, middle school, comes back from being homeschooled and she sort of sees the kind of politician Sonny who acts a certain way because his mother is principal of their school where he's sort of like a little bit friendly with everyone, but doesn't really have a ton of actual friends. And then she's sort of like, why are you talking to me like you're in a toothpaste commercial? Like something you are different to me. So I'm I'm interested also to see where that part of the story goes.
Sarah
06:19
Mm -hmm.
Tara
06:23
And also like when we see the pond before anything happens, there's already like a memorial plaque to all of the people who have died in it.
Sarah
06:31
With like
Tara
06:31
It's like, okay
Sarah
06:31
recent additions just sort of like
Tara
06:34
Stuck
Sarah
06:34
taped on there
Tara
06:35
on? Yeah.
Sarah
06:35
kind of.
Tara
06:36
Yes. So what's up with the pond?
Dave
06:38
Oh but I mean first of all, no way on earth this actually exists in the real universe. They're not putting a plaque up to the people that drowned in the pond with their first names on it. First of all, who in city council would actually be like, all right, here's your job? You gotta go around to every parent that's still alive for the kids, or husband, or wife, or sister, brother, and ask for permission to put their name on a plaque for them being really stupid at some point.
Tara
06:55
Sure. Mm-hmm.
Dave
07:03
And then addition to that, yeah, so that's a historical plaque. It looks exactly how you think it is, is one big metal piece that they've forged.
Tara
07:11
Mm-hmm.
Dave
07:11
And then below that, yeah, they got these little sort of like
Sarah
07:13
It's like the label maker tape editions.
Dave
07:15
No, no, it was metal. It was it was it wasn't stuck on, but it it had a very sort of um army lapel metal badge to it, stuck on with crazy glue kind of feel to it, yeah.
Tara
07:23
Yeah, yeah.
Sarah
07:24
Mm-hmm.
Tara
07:25
Yes, right.
Sarah
07:25
Yep.
Dave
07:26
But that was like, come on. And that was like the first thing they showed in the show. I'm like, uh-oh.
Tara
07:30
Mm-hmm.
Dave
07:31
But it got better.
Tara
07:32
Right. So for this show to work on any level, I think the viewer has to be invested in Ellen and Sonny's relationship pre-accident. Sarah, did it succeed on that level for you?
Sarah
07:43
It did because it didn't totally, if that makes any sense. Like I think there is a s more than a soup of creepy to their closeness
Tara
07:55
That
Sarah
07:55
which I would like to think is intentional, that it's kind of right on the line of like this world of two, like not inappropriate or untoward
Tara
08:03
's
Sarah
08:05
necessarily, but just like too invested and then early on she has this like wow wow stomp stomp stop slam
Tara
08:16
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
08:17
like barb moment that I was like okay Like, I'm I'm just not sure what we're supposed to make of that in terms of what we think Folin is up to. Or whether she's faux, or is this a is this a supernatural thing? Or but I think leaving that kind of ambiguous is Good. I did feel that she was a like trustworthy character up until the accident. I felt like she was trustworthy. Is that because we all just still think of her as Tammy Taylor?
Tara
08:50
Right, sure
Sarah
08:50
Possibly But that I think works in its favor that the the audience is carried along by previous projects, and I don't think that's a bad thing.
Tara
08:59
Speaking of Britain, doing press for this, she has talked about how vulnerable it is for her to play Ellen, knowing that viewers are going to be intensely scrutinizing her face. Because for the listener who is like Curious, but doesn't mind being spoiled. It is her in both, like it's still her. She's just had slight very slight changes prosthetically made to her face.
Sarah
09:18
Yeah. The Dern filter, it's
Tara
09:20
Yeah
Sarah
09:21
which also is a little unsettling once you realize who she looks more like, you're like
Tara
09:23
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
09:25
Okay, well that's also baggage of a sort
Tara
09:29
And it seems crazy to say the role takes bravery for her to play, but in our age of facial
Sarah
09:36
of
Tara
09:36
changes later in life. I think it actually it does take bravery for her to do this. I mean it helps that she is very beautiful. still
Sarah
09:44
Mm-hmm
Tara
09:44
in her fifties, but I had to note that as well. But elsewhere in the bars on the floor, I like that even though the protagonist is teen boy, the girls around him, Mallory who we mentioned and Chloe the girlfriend who are just as dimensional and also got funny stuff to do. Dave, what was your take on them?
Dave
10:02
Girls I wonder if they're going to do a uh subverting expectations where the homeschool girl ends up being like the worldly wise one because of her homeschooling and not the stupid person she would be coming back to class
Tara
10:17
Sure.
Dave
10:18
after being whole homeschooled. So we'll see about that. There are like little hints that like oh she gets it. She sees with clear eyes when everybody else here has been indoctrinated by the system. Um, but she's also kind of bad at things too, which makes it seem kind of grounded. There's a scene where he has the Costco card that shows her original face according to his version of events
Tara
10:40
Yeah, yes
Dave
10:43
and he needs to enhance it and f fucking finally they do an enhanced scene where like they go to the school scanner, they stick it in, and she's like literally trying to like magic marker.
Tara
10:54
Eyebrows.
Dave
10:54
digitally magic marker
Sarah
10:55
Eyebrows, yeah.
Dave
10:55
eyebrows into her
Tara
10:56
Yeah
Dave
10:57
and it just looks like a total clown show right away and she's like, Yeah maybe not.
Tara
11:02
Yeah, mm-hmm.
Dave
11:02
I thought was good. You know that's a nice little touch. Finally, enhance doesn't work. I mean Finally, only now in 2026 do we actually have enhanced technology.
Tara
11:12
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
11:13
I also appreciated that he did the voice. He's like, is it possible for you to like, I don't know, enhance? Like I appreciated that the show understood, like, this is stupid.
Tara
11:24
I have to give a shout out here for my favorite character, the one who is introduced saying he fell because his cousin was trying to get his good pen, and that is Weldon, a weirder kid at school Mallory's cousin who gets involved in the, you know, investigation into what happened with Ellen. And I thought every one of his lines was pretty funny. Uh everything he got to do was pretty funny. They kept him like legitimately weird the whole way through and he looks like a weird kid in high school. He's not like T V weird kid in high school, if you know what I mean.
Dave
11:54
Yeah yeah
Tara
11:55
So I think Sarah spoke to the world building. That's an example of where I thought this show h was more thoughtful than it really needed to be. And it's stuff like that that makes me want to keep watching too.
Dave
12:03
Yeah. high school package of that kind of kid, right?
Tara
12:15
Yeah.
Sarah
12:15
Mm-hmm
Dave
12:16
You know, like you can see him walking around three years later in a rush t shirt and he's not quite sure why.
Tara
12:20
Mm-hmm.
Dave
12:29
You know it's not getting mixed reviews. It's the theme to ask EHG is currently number negative one on the Billboard charts. That's two more than one. Just look it up. Don't worry about it. Alright, let's get into Ask Ask EHG judgment. Let's spin the wheel of judgment. It is Tara, Tara, you are the judge.
Tara
13:05
Hello, last week's question came from Whitty, who wrote, recently caught the season two premiere of Beverly Hills 90210. Oh, you're in for something. A plot, Brenda might be pregnant, B plot, Brandon is too good to work at the peach pit. What are other episodes of any show where two plot lines feel as mismatched as this? A couple of runners up, Erica wrote, Star Trek Deep Space Nine, Season 3, Episode 13, Life Support. A plot, Major Kira 's great love, beril. Thank you for the phonetic pronunciation by the way, has been in a shuttle accident and is slowly, painfully dying while also trying to negotiate peace with the Cardassians. At the end he passes away and Kira gives a beautiful monologue about how she fell in love with him. B plot teen friends Jake, Sisko and Nog go on a double date, and Nog is a bitch about it
Sarah
13:57
That
Dave
13:57
Wow.
Sarah
13:57
was the runner up? Oh
Dave
13:59
Yeah.
Tara
13:59
Yeah, another runner-up, David J.
Sarah
13:59
my gosh.
Tara
14:01
Snyder. The TNG episode Force of Nature ends with a well-meaning but poorly executed environmental metaphor about warp drive destroying subspace, but at the beginning it's mainly Geordie and Data talking about trying to train spot but our winner is Joel McHale joy people please change your names back it's impossible to tell who's who but There are a lot of glee episodes that I could pick from, but I'm going with glee season four episode eighteen shooting star. First of all, yikes A gun goes off in McKinley High and the school goes into active shooter mode. Meanwhile, there's a plot where Sam gets Britney another cat. Lady Tubington to go with Lord Tubington. Also, this aired in April twenty thirteen, four months after Sandy Hook. Stay classy, Glee. Jesus Christ. I guess this is the kind of thing we can look forward to when it comes back
Sarah
14:52
Oh
Tara
14:54
But good luck, Joel Mikhail Joy, whoever you actually are.
Sarah
14:56
,
Tara
14:58
Please DM Dave with your correct info to get your sticker.
Dave
15:02
Pretty sure that's Diana Joy.
Tara
15:04
Okay.
Dave
15:04
Yeah. Okay.
Tara
15:07
I believe you, I
Dave
15:08
Hm
Tara
15:08
just say
Dave
15:08
didn't sound like it. Alright, let's get to your questions for us. Jovial Gent has our first You just committed a crime. What non legal TV family would you want to be in court as your attorney, prosecutor, and judge? Turn.
Tara
15:22
Okay, I missed the family part, so these are unrelated people, sorry. Attorney is Monica Geller from Friends because she hates to lose. Prosecutor is Johnny Lawrence from Cobra Cai because he is a confident idiot and will not prepare. And the judge is Michael Kors, one of the few reality judges that I trust. Sorry that I did not meet the brief exactly. Sarah.
Sarah
15:44
The Sopranos. Meadow, my attorney, is smart and focused. The prosecutor, AJ, is an idiot. and beatable and the judge Janice has TV judge experience on SVU and can be bought if necessary.
Tara
15:57
Yeah.
Sarah
15:58
Dave.
Dave
15:59
I went with the Adams family. My attorney is Gomez. He's intimidating. He's willing to cheat. He's possibly supernatural-ish or has access to supernatural things. The prosecutor is the thing, has trouble making his case because he can't really communicate.
Sarah
16:10
Mm-hmm
Dave
16:14
And the judge is Uncle Fester. So even if they do prove their case, there's a 50-50 chance that you're just going to get off because he's uh just out to lunch.
Tara
16:21
I'd love that you call it the thing.
Dave
16:23
Yeah, the thing.
Sarah
16:24
Mm-hmm.
Tara
16:24
It's ch it's yeah, okay.
Dave
16:25
Yeah. Alright, fine.
Tara
16:26
Okay, Mom.
Dave
16:28
Alright. Well at least I uh read the question in full and underst
Tara
16:30
You at least you did.
Dave
16:32
yeah
Tara
16:32
Got me there.
Dave
16:32
now you see how you scum. D POV16. If you could add one feature to optimize TV viewing, what would it be, Sara D Bunting?
Sarah
16:41
Oh my god, level out the volume between programming and ads This is supposed to be illegal to boost the volume of commercials, but they do it anyway, and especially in this season, when it is both political ad season and postseason baseball season And you're just trying to watch a baseball game, it sucks when all of a sudden someone who actually thinks you're gonna vote for Tom Cain Jr. is screaming at you. Shut up, Dave.
Dave
17:05
I want linked text summaries of episodes for those shows that take so long to return. I have actually forgotten the details of the show in the 18 months that it's taken for it to come back
Sarah
17:13
Ooh, yeah.
Dave
17:16
for
Sarah
17:16
That's a gooder.
Dave
17:17
series two or if I just want to like skip ahead to the last episode because it's taking fucking forever to get there. See forty, fifty, sixty percent of the shows we've been talking about recently. And I'm just like, all right, just let me get to episode eight and give me the text summary. Done.
Tara
17:35
Make Apple TV and Netflix talk to each other. I've complained about this before, so that I know when a Netflix show comes back because otherwise There is literally no way. If it doesn't show up in my dashboard, I have to affirmatively seek it out. Like Netflix, do you think maybe this is why the viewership for your subsequent seasons of shows goes down? Just a thought And also speaking of Apple TV, make Iurs remember that the shows we watch that it thinks are Hulu are on Disney Plus If that is where we watched them the last time, stop overruling me and acting like you know better. You don't
Dave
18:11
Wow. Seth, it seems inevitable that a sentient AI will be a big bad on Cooper Tino. This was written a couple weeks ago. Womp womp. Who should embody the AI's avatar? Sam Elliott.
Tara
18:25
First of all, shout out to the person who does, Rob McClure, who we know from playing Trig Mullaney on The Good Fight. But it should be Brett Goldstein who in his first Several, I believe, seasons of Ted Lasso, many people thought was a CG generated character and not a real guy, Sarah.
Dave
18:41
Wow.
Tara
18:43
That is true.
Sarah
18:43
Uh
Dave
18:44
Because he looked too good or he looked too bad?
Tara
18:47
Kind of in between he just looks like he's been he looks like a video game character. Yeah, Sarah
Sarah
18:52
Mm-hmm. In the event that they change form, once they're no longer positioned as a chaotic good, in the show, Martin Starr.
Dave
19:01
Damon, what would be the worst possible casting for Joel McHale? Tara, worst possible casting
Tara
19:07
A sensitive romantic type a la JD in Scrubs. Dave.
Dave
19:13
Doctor Who, sir
Sarah
19:16
Hannah in the girls reboot.
Dave
19:18
Bees or Laura, over the course of time, which song do you think has gotten stuck in your head the most? Not necessarily meaning it's your favorite song, because Bezoar Laura can say, hers is Skater Boy. Alright, that's stuck in her head. What's stuck in your head, Sarah?
Sarah
19:33
Soldier Boy has gotta be it. Family-wide problem. Uh somewhere my brother was just like, god damn it, and he doesn't know why. But Copa Cabana, also in the conversation, her name was Lola. She was a showgirl. I don't know if you guys heard. Tara.
Tara
19:50
I've talked about this before, it's the reason we had to stop watching it before bed. The theme song to the Mary Tyler Moore show is extremely catchy and it will lodge in your brain. Dave.
Dave
20:00
My answer my answer is Sanford Sanford the Sun Gee Boo. I think first question from Gee Boo. Did you have pets when you were kids? Alright, here's here's my new take. Alright, this question comes from Gebu. Beep segment edited. It was
Sarah
20:21
Thank you.
Dave
20:21
grim
Tara
20:22
Too grim.
Dave
20:23
Grim
Sarah
20:23
No good
Dave
20:26
All right. Well, Rynsey has our next question. Did you have to be in the secret super club to get that content
Sarah
20:36
No , the secret super club is canceled.
Dave
20:39
Rynsey, did you ever find out the repercussions of not closing the food portal the other week? Anybody have any weird food occurrences that they uh were uh a little worried about after that?
Sarah
20:51
I did.
Dave
20:52
Uh-huh.
Tara
20:52
Oh, okay.
Sarah
20:52
The local diner absolutely bricked an egg sandwich order that they've done a million times without incident, like it was the wrong egg preparation. They forgot the tomatoes and they're like, oh sorry, we'll make it again. And like this has happened once an in the past, but like I have Dan check it when he goes to pick it up because if they put bacon on mine, it's like, all right, I can't. I'm not eating that. So Check it on site. So they remade it. He was looking at his phone. They put bacon on it. And he's like, Well, okay, no. And now you gotta make it again.
Tara
21:23
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
21:24
She's vegetarian. And they're like, so she wants shrimp on it? And he's like, no. And then they used the wrong cheese this the last time, but he was like, I couldn't stand there anymore. I just had to leave and accept. Except what we got, but uh it didn't occur to me that it was a food portal related problem
Dave
21:44
Ripple effect.
Sarah
21:44
until now.
Dave
21:45
Yeah.
Sarah
21:46
Yeah.
Dave
21:46
So you don't have an answer for this turn?
Tara
21:48
Uh yeah, it made me buy Wilted Basil yesterday.
Dave
21:52
Oh yeah, right. Yeah, you really fucked up there.
Tara
21:54
Mm-hmm.
Dave
21:54
My my advice to anybody who's buying produce at the grocery store, um, look at it.
Tara
22:00
Hey. It 's a little little clamshell, okay?
Dave
22:04
Yeah, turn it over.
Tara
22:06
All right.
Dave
22:08
The secret was turning it over.
Tara
22:10
Uh-huh.
Dave
22:11
Well, Michael Imperioli
Sarah
22:11
No.
Dave
22:13
came to my home and slowly hand fed me cold udon noodles, which was very unsettling. And he said, this is what happens when you don't close the portal.
Sarah
22:18
Hmm, I bet
Dave
22:21
And speaking about, we're gonna close the portal right now.
Clip
22:23
Enough! I'm so sick and tired of hearing you people talk about food, food, food.
Dave
22:27
Alright, let's bookend this with Jovial Jen. What petty, non-deadly curse would you like to cast on your enemies, Sarah D. Bunting? Finally! Everything is coming up, Sarah.
Sarah
22:37
And I cast it daily, no would like to about it. Me Penises bloom on your grave. I cast it daily. You can't street park at Bay Ridge, Brooklyn, without a go-to hex, and I wouldn't try. Dave.
Dave
22:50
Uncontrollable farting when you're making out. Tar
Tara
22:54
Whenever you start your car, the fuel light is on.
Dave
22:59
Oh no. And then like you're done. That's it. You're done.
Tara
23:02
Yep.
Dave
23:02
Yep. Bezoar Laura has your ask ask EHG question for you to answer. Bezoar Laura asks. excluding actors who are actually related, what's the best parent-child casting you have ever seen? Put your answer in our Ask Ask EHG channel on Discord or you can answer right on the episode page on our site. Alright, you ready, lady?
Tara
23:25
Yep.
Dave
23:25
You're ready?
Tara
23:26
Yep.
Dave
23:26
You ready to do this?
Tara
23:28
Yes
Dave
23:28
Well then here we go! It is time for the tiny cannon presenting. This week it is tar.
Tara
23:36
It is Tara
Dave
23:37
Yeah.
Tara
23:37
David Letterman's late night shows, Late Night and The Late Show, had no shortage of recurring segments that during the monoculture became beloved fixtures. Everyone knows about stupid pet tricks, stupid human tricks, the top ten list Superfans, hello, fondly remember, will it float, is this anything, and special for the winter holidays. The annual attempt by Jay Thomas to knock an enormous meatball off the top of the late show Christmas tree by throwing a football at it, followed by the singing of Christmas, Baby Please Come Home by the great Darlene Love. We miss her. And every Halloween we'd get a parade of adorable kids in costumes. Here's why I think the segment as a whole and this outing in particular deserves a place in the tiny holiday segment canon. Number one, it's meta trappings. One of the best Daves is calling out the artifice of what we're doing, Dave, which we get immediately here. Clip one.
Clip
24:30
Ladies and gentlemen, it's my house. Doesn't it, doesn't it just scream, Martha Stewart?
Tara
24:38
Refusing to act like anything he ever does is important with a capital I is a lesson Dave can still teach the comedy writers and performers of our day. Later in the segment, a kid comes out in glasses, a headset, and a button-down shirt stuffed with a fake belly. Clip two.
Clip
24:57
Ladies and gentlemen, take a look right here. It's one of the most beloved members of our late show family. That's right, none other than one of our stage managers. Biff Henderson. How you doing, buddy? Biff, come on in here. Here he is, ladies and gentlemen. Biff Henderson. For you, we have a scoop of egg salad. There you are. Thank you very much. Happy Halloween. I know you want something else, don't you?
Tara
25:34
Dave started using crew members and sketches to earn them a little extra money to get paid, I think, scale for being on camera, while also enmeshing fans in the world of the show. I knew and loved Biff, Alan, Pat, Tony, Barbara, Morty, and every member of the band long before I ever learned the term parasociality. You can tell from the ovation that greets little Biff well before Dave identifies him that I was not alone. Number two, Dave plus kids equals adorable. I will probably never get sick of watching Dave making friends with every dog that ever showed up to perform a stupid pet trick. Human children are not as interesting to me, but watching Dave interact with them is fun to watch for the same reasons. He wants to make them comfortable and set them up to succeed. hence his practice in this segment of steadying them with a single hand on their heads to make sure they don't wander off their mark. And their absolute bafflement at Dave talking to them like they're adults and or putting a carpet remnant in their treat bags is, in its way, dog like. Something all children should aspire to, in my opinion, clip three.
Clip
26:36
Hey kids, how you doing? How you kids doing? Hey kids, kids, by the way, the kids love me Hey kids, how you doing? Nice to see you. Hey happy Halloween. Look what we have for you. We have cedar shoe trees. There you go. One for you.
Tara
26:50
Number three, the topical costumes are a time capsule of what we were all talking about 30 years ago this month. Let's say first that the kids of America wish they had the resources of a 1990s era network variety show to make their Halloween costumes. That said, my favorite one in this segment is probably the easiest to pull off. Clip four.
Clip
27:10
I don't want the damn egg salad. Let's see who this is. Hi, come right on in. Oh, look at this. He's hip, he's happening, he's single, but sorry girls, he's in prison. Say hello to everyone's favorite troubled loner, Ted Kaczynski, the unibomber.
Tara
27:26
Ted's distinguished company includes President Clinton's lunch, four fast food sandwiches. Shredded Whitewater documents, like if you tried to make a Chewbacca costume out of paper, Dennis Rodman, kid with green hair in a sequin dress, remember when that was all it took to shock a nation? Ross Porot's ears and Bob Dole the day after the election were delivering pizza for Dominoes. He was in fact a Pizza Hut man since the first location was in his home state of Kansas, but yeah. Number four, the evergreen costumes remind us why Dave 's is the comedy we vibe with clip five.
Clip
28:02
Oh, there's the doorbell. Let's open it right up. Here now is the perfect Halloween costume for the American boy or girl lacking drive, outside interests, and never leaving the house. That's right. Look, it's a doorstop. Hi, honey, how are you? I'm great, how are you? Fine, fine. Happy Halloween. What is your name? Holly. Holly? All right, and we have a little something for you. We have a bottle of Liz Taylor perfume. Don't open it in the car.
Tara
28:29
If you don't think a sweet little third grader wearing over her shoulders a giant doorstop, probably taller than she is, we maybe can't be friends. Vote this into the tiny holiday segment canon or I am sending egg salad to your house regular mail.
Dave
28:44
Thank you, Tara Sarah.
Sarah
28:47
It really is the traits that make this, of course Dave is clearly having a ball. The kids sometimes look a little scared, but he does steady them, like you mentioned. But the scoop of egg salad and then the callback that it's like, sorry, we're all out of egg salad
Tara
29:05
Yeah, I think it's a good one.
Sarah
29:05
There's a self-pitying bit about Cabin Boy, which every legendary segment must contain. I'm not sure what would have been weirder. for the studio audience that day, the Dennis Rodman costume or George Steinbrenner's time in the guest chair, but
Tara
29:22
Yes, mm-hmm
Sarah
29:23
this is, I think, very typical of 90s Dave. It doesn't have any of the things that would maries Dave segment. Like sometimes he could verge a little sour about stuff. There's nothing super inappropriate. Like, I don't know. true crime costumes are to me no go. But he has a way about him. He has that Dave way that That sells it. And uh the Ross Pro ears made me laugh. I am still laughing it. We're all out of exile. It's just it's just good. And it's exactly the right length It's the right number of kids, it's the right kids, it's the right blend of costumes. Perfect. Very typical Dave segment, but also very memorable. Dave's segment, and now I kind of want an egg salad sandwich, and we may have to close the food portal again.
Dave
30:12
Ugh.
Sarah
30:13
Dave.
Dave
30:14
Big salad yuck. The one thing that made me laugh when I wasn't expecting it is the kid that got the Yanni live of the Acropolis CD as their
Tara
30:22
Yeah
Sarah
30:23
No.
Dave
30:23
That's their treat. I don't know why that
Sarah
30:25
You just looked horrified, this poor child.
Dave
30:28
just that moment in time where Yani
Tara
30:28
, I don't know.
Dave
30:31
C D was a thing I mostly like this near here's this political thing and they're gonna talk about it until until her eyes bleed that was white water That part felt a little flat to me. But overall the segment really worked. It went fast. Like they were like ding dong as soon as the one kid was done, immediately the doorbell rang again. You open the door, you know, we have like seven or eight kids or something like that in six minutes. So it went really fast, which I wasn't expecting because usually a live to tape show is all about eating clock, as Sarah D. Bunting likes to say.
Sarah
31:04
Mm-hmm
Dave
31:05
And I didn't really get that impression here. You know, they had six minutes and they packed a lot into it. The door stop was the first costume, and that was definitely the one I would want. It was really well done.
Tara
31:14
Yeah
Dave
31:15
It's that
Sarah
31:16
Yeah.
Dave
31:16
Brown doorstop with the ridge top, you know, you know if you've ever seen those ones.
Sarah
31:19
Mm-hmm.
Tara
31:19
Mm-hmm.
Sarah
31:20
Yeah, that
Tara
31:20
Platonic ideal doorstop.
Dave
31:22
Exactly the same doorstop
Tara
31:22
Mm-hmm.
Dave
31:24
you can buy today. We have not improved doorstep technology.
Tara
31:26
Nope
Dave
31:27
Classic segment. I don't think it's right up there in the public imagination with stupid pet tricks and stuff like that, but it is a mainstay and I think it deserves to be in the canon. The egg salad bit was absolutely great. The callback to it, fantastic. The way he plops the egg salad into the bags.
Tara
31:48
Mm-hmm.
Dave
31:49
Cause one of them does it doesn't quite get in there the first time, he's n hasing to like violently shake it out. That was pretty funny
Sarah
31:55
It's like wiping it on the inside of the bag.
Dave
31:57
But yeah, um I enjoyed it despite some of the hack political stuff in it.
Sarah
31:57
Ugh.
Dave
32:01
Yep. All right, let's put this to the vote. Sarah D. Bunting
Sarah
32:04
Yes
Dave
32:05
Me too. So new Halloween costumes from the late show of David Letterman. You're hereby inducted into the extra hot great tiny holiday programming canon.
Clip
32:15
Americans love a winner. Yeah. And will not tolerate a loser. Nope.
Dave
32:21
It is time for the not quite winners and losers of the week segment. I will go first. My not quite winner is Nick. Kroll, he's going to be hosting and EP the American version of uh Last One Laughing. We talked about the UK version a few months ago. I think Nick Kroll would make a good host. I'm unconvinced that an American version of this would work. Because I just don't think America is very good at panel show and panel show adjacent stuff. And then not quite loser of the week is Revival. It's been canceled at SIFIafter a single season, but don't worry, it'll be back in about two years.
Tara
32:57
My sister came up recently, just want to give her a shout out because she told me to watch this on Netflix because one of her clients at her store is in it because it's obviously Filmed in Canada. I haven't seen to that man, I am sorry that this happened to you.
Sarah
33:14
To this man, I am excited that it happened. My not quite winner is True Detective, which has officially cast Nicolas Cage for season five, opposite Antonio Banderas. That is casting I like. I am excited about it. Good for him. Not quite loser. Unsolved Mysteries got downgraded to a video podcast? Although I'm not sure if downgraded is even the right term because so much of Netflix has downgraded itself to video podcasts that they're like new in the true crime space this week on Netflix. And it's just like a podcast that they filmed. So no thanks. The new reboot on Netflix was well received. I can't imagine they couldn't have found the money to keep doing it the way they were doing it, but
Tara
34:03
Well, they didn't care to. This is gonna be on YouTube.
Sarah
34:05
Yeah, no, I I know, but I don't understand
Tara
34:07
Okay.
Sarah
34:09
I just don't understand why they let this IP go. It's kind of a license to print money with a certain Gen X weirdo cohort As we heard in a drunk history segment the other day on the main podcast, so I don't I don't get it. It's a shame. And I hope Robert Stack haunts them all. Tara.
Tara
34:27
My not quite winner of the week is the Hulu True Crime Scripted Series, the dropout, the one about Elizabeth Holmes. Which has seen a 186% viewership spike in the wake of the feature film documentary. You can see everything also about Elizabeth. from Nathan Field or which sidebar, uh, see this movie. See it in as crowded a theaters you can find, because it is a real trip. Don't be scared by the three-hour runtime. It flies. I was shocked when I when it ended and I looked at what time it was. Um so strong recommend for that. My not quite loser of the week is and this came up earlier too, Disney Plus and Hulu, green lighting a glee revival. No one seems to want I mean the reaction to this announcement has as far as I can tell, been uniformly, please do not do this. A show that has a spin-off recap podcast hosted by two former stars where every episode is basically here's every fucking thing they did wrong. Maybe not IP you can revive, but Lea Michele is signed on to reprise her role as Rachel Berry, so that's one, I guess we'll see.
Dave
35:35
Did we ever get to the bottom whether she could read or not?
Tara
35:38
Nope.
Sarah
35:39
Who's just gonna ask that?
Dave
35:39
Okay.
Tara
35:40
We have not, so as someone on the Discord joked, it's possible she signed the contract without reading it.
Dave
35:45
That's right. X. Hey everybody speaking about can't read and performing poorly, do you know what time it is?
Tara
35:54
It's good.
Sarah
35:54
Oh, Jesus, solicitor
Tara
35:55
For listeners
Sarah
35:56
cape time.
Dave
35:59
I don't remember what happened. Please don't connect what I just said to any performances in the show. Well, well, this is the fourth game time of the month, the month of Amy Allenspach. Five trivia mina games to test your knowledge of the computer bits and gourmet bites. of television history. Here's our scores so far after the last very spicy performances. Kim with two, Elenore with the tiebreaker victory, giving her one. Sarah still looking to get on the board. Today we are playing a game called Tin Can Noises, Amy explains. In this game you will get a series of clues that describe a wedding and you need to name the show the wedding is from. If you can get in one clue, you get three points, two clues, two points, and after three clues, it is worth one point. Here is your example. The year is 2018. The wedding is held in Brooklyn, but their plans go awry when a bomb threat is made. Now, nobody here knows the answer. Look at them, they're all shaking their heads, so let me give you another clue. The bride's ex-boyfriend Teddy is the leader of the anti-bomb squad. Oh my god, nobody knows it still. The wedding cake is a replica of Nakatomi Plaza. Alright, what do you think? What's that show?
Kim
37:23
Brooklyn nine
Dave
37:24
Brooklyn 99, Elenore won't say it.
Kim
37:24
nine
Dave
37:26
She's on a Brooklyn 999 diet. But you are correct, Kim. It is Brooklyn 99. That was Jake and Amy's wedding, but you just named the show. Let's throw it to Piggy Choose going first.
Clip
37:39
We will start with valued guest.
Dave
37:41
All right, we will start with Kim, go to Elenore, then Sarah. We've got 18 questions, one Grosswift Equalizer Challenge zoned in the middle. Are we ready to play tin can noises?
Sarah C
37:52
Bing
Elenore
37:52
Let's go
Kim
37:52
Yeah.
Sarah C
37:52
Bang
Dave
37:53
Kim, it is the year 2000. The episode in question is called Ode to Joy. You guess at every level without penalty.
Kim
38:03
I believe that's Beverly Hills 90210.
Dave
38:05
You are good for three points, yes, that is Donna and David's wedding. Elenore
Kim
38:09
Thank thank you again with this.
Elenore
38:10
Yikes
Dave
38:12
2012. The couple get married before the groom goes into space.
Elenore
38:20
I think I didn't
Dave
38:21
The wedding takes place on the roof of the Madison Luxury Apartments in Pasadena.
Elenore
38:25
know I'll take another hat
Dave
38:28
Five ministers, thus in quotes, give speeches before the couple exchange vows. What's that wedding from?
Elenore
38:38
I don't know
Dave
38:39
No.
Sarah C
38:42
Steel meal
Dave
38:43
A steel meal invocation has been made, but let's quickly check with Tara for the current steel meal situation, please.
Tara
38:48
Okay, Sarah has two, Elenore has one, Kim has three.
Dave
38:52
All right, Sarah, here we go. What is that show?
Sarah C
38:56
For all mankind.
Dave
38:58
Incorrect
Sarah C
38:59
Ooh
Kim
39:00
I'll do how do you steal me?
Dave
39:01
Kim Kim wants to do a steel meal.
Kim
39:03
It's the Big Bang Theory.
Dave
39:04
Yes, that is good for one point on the steel.
Kim
39:05
It's the dumber for for all mankind
Sarah C
39:08
Yes
Dave
39:09
Very similar. Remember in uh Big Bang Theory when Leonard went out into the moon with all that duct tape?
Sarah C
39:15
Yeah.
Dave
39:16
And he died?
Tara
39:16
The classic
Dave
39:17
All right, Sarah, here comes your first full question. The year 2012. The couple get hitched so the bride can't incriminate the groom in a crime.
Sarah C
39:27
No, no, no.
Dave
39:28
The episode was filmed near the Bethesda Terrace and Fountain in Central Park, New York City.
Sarah C
39:35
Prince
Dave
39:36
Friends, not correct. Good guess. The episode is called New York I Love You XOXO
Sarah C
39:43
Uh, let me say the sopranos
Dave
39:47
Incorrect. We were looking for Gossip Girl. That's Blair and Chuck.
Sarah C
39:52
Oh well, yes, but
Dave
39:52
XOXO was your clue for Gossip Girl there.
Elenore
39:53
XL, XL
Dave
39:55
Back to Kim. 2007. What is supposed to be a departmental dinner turns out to be a surprise wedding
Kim
40:06
Um parks and rack
Dave
40:10
The episode is titled I Don't
Kim
40:14
I don't. Um, the office
Dave
40:18
The bride recites an excerpt from the E. E. Cummings poem I Carry Your Heart With Me. Point of order. The game master has capitalized E. E. Cummings, and I think that's against All E. E. Cummings regulations
Kim
40:31
Oh, I think we have to throw this question out. Um, no, I do not know.
Dave
40:37
All right, the answer there was Luca and Abby from ER.
Elenore
40:41
From ER
Kim
40:43
Oh
Dave
40:43
Back to Elenore. 2011? The bride and groom exchanged twist ties rather than rings, the twist ties they use in their dry run a week earlier.
Elenore
40:54
I'll take the first hint.
Dave
40:56
The groom enlists his wedding party to take down Vivian Volkoff and stop her from destroying the big day.
Elenore
41:04
Oh, I know less than I did when you first asked the question. I'll take the second hit, please.
Dave
41:09
Okay. The episode title is Blank versus the cliffhanger where blank is the groom's name that we can't use because it's also in the show title. Blank
Elenore
41:20
Stop that
Dave
41:20
versus the cliffhanger
Elenore
41:21
in
Dave
41:23
of 2011.
Elenore
41:24
Are there any more hints available?
Dave
41:26
Uh just that um I uh no
Elenore
41:32
Okay.
Dave
41:32
I had something that I lost. No, no more hins love.
Elenore
41:35
Shows with someone's name or just character's name. Um friends
Dave
41:43
We were looking for Chuck. Chuck versus the cliffhanger from Chuck, Sarah's and Chucks. wedding, I don't want to say Chuck any more.
Elenore
41:52
Great
Dave
41:52
Sarah
Elenore
41:53
chuck
Sarah C
41:54
Yes
Dave
41:54
2018. The bride wore a custom made forty-five carat floral diamond tiara
Sarah C
41:59
,
Dave
42:01
valued at two hundred thousand dollars.
Sarah C
42:05
Um stupid six in the city
Dave
42:10
The wedding took place in the building that gives the show its name.
Sarah C
42:15
Uh the thirty rock
Dave
42:22
The wedding is set in the spring of 1920.
Sarah C
42:30
Uh, let me say uh Opera Wars
Dave
42:37
Incorrect. That was Steel Mill. Did I hear Steamil?
Elenore
42:41
Yeah.
Dave
42:41
Steel Mill from Elenore.
Elenore
42:43
Is that Downton Abbey?
Dave
42:44
That is Downtown Abbey.
Elenore
42:46
Yes
Dave
42:46
Good for one point, Matthew and Mary. Back to Kim 2001. The episode is called Just Harried. Just Harried.
Kim
42:56
Just Harried.
Dave
42:58
Yeah.
Kim
42:59
Um two thousand one.
Dave
43:01
Yep.
Kim
43:02
Oh I've nothing. Uh hint please
Dave
43:05
The wedding takes place in the family manor in San Francisco.
Kim
43:10
Oh, is it charmed?
Dave
43:11
It is charm, good for two points. Your final clue was Grams binds the coupled to their vows with a cord. Leo and Piper. Back to Elenore 2004. There's a blizzard that cuts off the band and photographer from the festivities.
Elenore
43:27
I'll take the hint.
Dave
43:28
The groom decides it would be fun to have his dog Chappie as a groomsman.
Elenore
43:33
I'll take another hand
Dave
43:34
The wedding ends up being held outside of the group's favorite cafe in New York.
Elenore
43:39
Friends
Dave
43:41
You are corrected as friends that was Phoebe and Mike's wedding
Elenore
43:43
Finally, shout out to the friends
Dave
43:47
Alright, Sarah, you'll take us into our first scorebreak. The wedding is from an episode in 1991. The groom goes skydiving on the morning of his wedding.
Sarah C
43:59
Uh, let me say I keep thinking of 1970s cop shows. What is wrong with me? 1991, what were we watching? Uh we It was an innocent time. We were watching Hint
Dave
44:16
Can I
Sarah C
44:16
Please
Dave
44:17
can I okay good? He says, Have mercy as he jumps out of the plane.
Sarah C
44:24
Mercy hint, please.
Dave
44:26
The groom is arrested for ruining the crop of tomatoes and ends up in jail while the bride waits at the altar.
Sarah C
44:32
No, I no idea. Sorry. I can't think of anything. I can't think of any show at all
Dave
44:36
Alright.
Sarah C
44:37
now that friends. Yes, it was very good
Dave
44:40
The answer we're looking for is Full House, Becky and Jesse's wedding from Full House.
Sarah C
44:43
Oh, never seen a frame of it.
Dave
44:46
Alright, let's get the scores, please, Tar.
Tara
44:49
Okay. Kim has six, Elenore has two, Sarah looking to get on the board.
Dave
44:55
All right, let's get right back to it.
Elenore
44:56
Yay
Dave
44:57
Kim 2004. The episode is called Last Week Fights, This Week Tights.
Kim
45:04
Okay. I think that's Gilmore Girls.
Dave
45:07
You are correct. Three points.
Elenore
45:09
Oh wow,
Dave
45:10
Yes.
Sarah C
45:10
I
Dave
45:10
That was TJ and Liz from Gilmore Girls.
Sarah C
45:11
think
Dave
45:14
Elenore 2011. The couple delay their wedding to treat a John Doe who came in after being hit by a bus.
Elenore
45:22
Crazy Nature
Dave
45:23
You are correct for three points, yes, Meredith and Derek.
Sarah C
45:25
Wow.
Dave
45:26
Sarah
Sarah C
45:27
Yes.
Dave
45:28
2007.
Sarah C
45:30
Mm-hmm.
Dave
45:30
The wedding takes place in Atlantic City in a park to avoid judgment from the groom's family.
Sarah C
45:36
Hint, please.
Dave
45:37
Scooter, the bride's high school boyfriend, shows up at the wedding. The bride's cousin gives the groom highlighted tips in his hair, and in an attempt to correct it, he shaves off a patch of hair on his head.
Sarah C
45:51
Hint, please.
Dave
45:53
My hint is you're out of hands.
Sarah C
45:57
I'm out
Dave
46:00
That is your favorite show ever with Lillian Marshall, How I Met Your Mother. Back to Kim 2016. The episode is called Chapter 44.
Kim
46:13
Oh, okay. So what show use chapters? They're titles And would this have been episode 44? So it would have been 2016. I don't know. Give me a hint.
Dave
46:28
The bride changes her graduate thesis to an intergenerational story about her family.
Kim
46:34
Huh. Oh, is it uh Jane the Virgin?
Dave
46:39
Yes, it is Jane the Virgin, Jane and Raphael.
Kim
46:40
Okay. Oh
Dave
46:42
Two points.
Kim
46:42
Phew
Dave
46:43
Back to Elenore 2020. During the wedding, the town's female a cappella group performs two songs.
Elenore
46:51
You know, so many towns have a female a cappella group
Dave
46:56
Yep. I just want to remind you, Gilmore Girls off the table.
Elenore
47:00
Exactly.
Dave
47:02
Quirky small town dromedies. That one's gone. Next clue.
Elenore
47:05
I'll take the hit.
Dave
47:07
The mother of the groom officiates the wedding after Fabian, the original officiant haikuist, cancelled. as he did not want to have to travel in bad weather on a penny farthing. This might out quirk Gilmore girls, frankly, judging by that clue.
Elenore
47:21
Yeah, this is this is tearing me apart.
Dave
47:23
That's too much quirk.
Elenore
47:25
Uh
Dave
47:25
That's a quirk.
Elenore
47:26
yeah, I'll take the final hint, please
Dave
47:28
A pre-wedding message ends in a happy ending, giving this episode its title. I don't think happy ending is meant to be sexual here, but it's in quotes, so I'm just gonna uh put that mustard on it.
Elenore
47:41
Yeah, I glee.
Dave
47:46
What if I told you this show was on Pop TV?
Elenore
47:49
Damn it. I already forgot the show from POP TV.
Dave
47:51
Yeah, I thought you would have. Shitskreak. David and Patrick.
Elenore
47:54
Yep, there we go.
Dave
47:56
Alright, back to Sarah, 1992. The minister has a heart attack and dies in the kitchen before the wedding, leaving an intoxicated uncle Roger to stand in.
Sarah C
48:09
Uh, let me say uh Ally McBeal.
Dave
48:14
The bride's family hosts the wedding at their mansion, but their Dobermans attack everyone who tries to walk past.
Sarah C
48:21
Um Falcon Cristó
Dave
48:25
Yeah, I like that guess. The bride's family enlist a main character to provide liquor and bartending services at the wedding.
Sarah C
48:35
Uh gosh. Uh let me say moonlighting.
Dave
48:41
No, that was your big clue there. Provide liquor and bartending services at the
Elenore
48:44
There's no steel I don't have any steel meals left, right?
Tara
48:47
That's correct.
Sarah C
48:48
You can have my
Elenore
48:49
Okay.
Sarah C
48:49
you can have mine. I'm I'm not using them.
Elenore
48:50
No, no.
Dave
48:50
Elenore let us know what it is, just for shits and grins.
Elenore
48:53
Cheers
Dave
48:54
Cheers, yes, Woody and Kelly's wedding from
Sarah C
48:55
Oh no.
Kim
48:56
Um
Dave
48:56
cheers. Okay, everybody's last question is here. Let's get this course, please. Tara.
Tara
49:02
Okay, Kim has eleven, Elner
Clip
49:05
That's the that's the
Tara
49:06
has five, Sarah
Clip
49:06
back of the
Tara
49:08
still looking to get on the board
Clip
49:08
other
Dave
49:09
All right, I know we can do it, Sarah.
Clip
49:10
bundle.
Dave
49:11
Well let's find out. All right, Kim twenty sixteen. The groom tries to convince the bride's mother to come to the wedding, but he gets stuck on a plane and misses the ceremony.
Kim
49:23
Um, the ground trut
Dave
49:26
So the groom tries to convince the bride's mother to come to the wedding, but he gets stuck on a plane and misses it.
Kim
49:31
Uh, I'll need a hint, please.
Dave
49:33
The groom calls into the wedding party via video chat virtually attending the outdoor wedding.
Kim
49:40
Another hint
Dave
49:42
Eventually, the couple celebrate in a small ceremony that takes place at the loft where most of the central characters on the show live.
Kim
49:50
Oh, um, New Girl.
Dave
49:51
New girl, Cece and Schmidt. Yes, correct. All right, this is question 17.
Kim
49:57
It's pretty
Sarah C
49:57
Spanning on
Dave
49:58
It is for Elenore 2009 The couple originally planned to get married in a church, but they secretly eloped on the maid of the missboat in Niagara Falls.
Elenore
50:08
That is the office.
Dave
50:09
That is the office for three points. Which office?
Elenore
50:14
Uh, an American tale.
Dave
50:15
Yes, an America tale, thank you. Jim and Pam there, of course. All right, last question of regulation is for Sarah. Sarah, we're all rooting for you. I'm gonna give you a clue.
Sarah C
50:23
Yes
Dave
50:24
This, the answer is a show that you guessed incorrectly before at some point. So something come out of your mouth. Here we go.
Sarah C
50:32
Dave, over the last three weeks I have guessed so many incorrections. It could be literally anything.
Dave
50:39
2012. The couple is anxious to adopt and start a family on their own, so they opt for a quick wedding to help the process.
Sarah C
50:46
Uh, thirty
Dave
50:47
30 rock is correct for three points.
Sarah C
50:47
rock
Dave
50:52
Alright, that is regulation. Scores, please try.
Tara
50:54
All right, Sarah finished with three, Elenore had eight, and Kim is our victor with twelve.
Dave
51:03
Nicely done.
Elenore
51:04
Wow
Dave
51:05
All right, before we get into making that official. Let's play the tiebreaker for a steel mill. And Kim, you're out on this one. You got too many. You got too many. You're too many too good.
Kim
51:13
Okay, that's why
Dave
51:14
All right, so Sarah, Elenore, here we go.
Kim
51:14
I'm not sure.
Dave
51:16
The year is nineteen sixty nine. The bride wears a fashionable yellow dress and veil.
Sarah C
51:23
Mar uh Mary uh
Elenore
51:24
General Hospital
Sarah C
51:24
Mary Talamosha.
Dave
51:25
Both incorrect, the couple decide to bring all of their children on the honeymoon
Sarah C
51:31
Oh, uh
Elenore
51:32
The pretty
Sarah C
51:32
Brady
Dave
51:32
Pretty much
Sarah C
51:32
Bunch
Elenore
51:32
bunch.
Dave
51:33
going to give that one to Sarah, pretty much at the same time, but Sarah is on the other side of the world, so I think maybe she got it first. Alright, so that's a steel meal for Sarah. And once again, Kim is our victor.
Clip
51:47
Valued guest.
Dave
51:48
Did I say Wictor? Yes I did. I was doing my checkoff impression and it's very good Alright guys, that is it for another episode of Extra Extra Hot Great. We discussed whether or not phony was the real deal before going. Before answering your burning Ask EACquestions like, who's playing AI on Cupertino and where are we miscasting Joel McHale? After her tiny holiday programming cannip pitch, Tara found only treats in her little bag. We celebrated those who were quite the best and worst of the week and wrapped it all up. With another Kim Victory and listener game time by Amy. Next up is Newlyweds on EHGprime. Remember.
Clip
52:31
We're listening.
Dave
52:34
I am David T. Cole and on behalf of Tarie Ariano
Tara
52:37
That kid got my unclaimed dry cleaning.
Dave
52:40
and Sarah D. Bunting.
Sarah
52:42
I got a P and P
Dave
52:44
Thanks for listening everyone and we'll see you next time right here on Extra Extra Hot Great
Clip
53:02
Thank you very much. Happy Halloween. I know you want something else, don't you?